Programming a full evening of music for the Chicago Symphony’s brass section carries a certain responsibility. ‘
“If we’re going to do something, it has to be spectacular,” said trombonist and conductor Michael Mulcahy, looking ahead to the annual winter concert, this season on Dec. 15. “The audience comes every year, expecting something out of the box. It’s a high-electricity event. It’s amazing to see Orchestra Hall packed to the rafters.”
The concert has been a tradition since 2006, and Mulcahy has led it every year except the first. “The brass section has been a conspicuous part of this orchestra for so long,” he said, “and we aspired to do something special beyond our jobs.”
Chicago’s brass has carried a vaunted reputation for generations, but Mulcahy sees the tradition as “artistic opportunity rather than pressure.” The important qualities, he said, include “purity of unforced sound, pre-eminence of line, sustaining a singing sensibility, embracing a massive spectrum of dynamics, especially the softs, and always respecting the composer’s intention.”
Relatively little music has been written originally for large brass ensemble. “It’s a real pain to find quality pieces that are compatible with each other and technically feasible,” Mulcahy said. Also, every piece requires different instrumentation, and he has to balance workload when he is scheduling musicians. The core of the group is the permanent CSO roster, but experienced freelance extras will fill out the complement of six trumpets, five horns, four trombones, two tubas and three percussionists.
While trying to put together a balanced program, Mulcahy draws from as wide a variety of sources as he can. This year will feature original music by Edward Gregson and Kevin Puts, as well as arrangements of pieces by Gershwin and Vaughan Williams. “I never want to play just popular music or transcriptions,” Mulcahy said, although in the past, the group has done settings of pieces by Brahms, Ravel, Chabrier and many more. “A Chicago brass concert should have the integrity of a Chicago Symphony Orchestra concert.”
Conducting the musicians whom he usually sits aside is a challenge, Mulcahy said. “You don’t have authority like the music director does. Everyone has a history with everyone else, and relations aren’t always simple, but my job is to galvanize and unify and enable the team to do as well as they can do. I try to have a light hand, and I try to have a sense of humor.”
For the annual brass concert, the forces involved are large enough that a conductor is basically a requirement. If every musician is giving input, “it’s much more labor-intensive,” Mulcahy said. But it also depends on the repertoire; he remembers one time when his quintet asked for a conductor to help get through a thorny piece by the modernist Elliott Carter. Making that admission may feel “almost like going to the dark side,” he said, joking, “but it shouldn’t.”
Mulcahy has been a member of the CSO’s trombone section since 1989, but he finds time for conducting when he can. “I’ve been playing in orchestras for 50 years, and I’ve seen a lot,“ he said. ”I watch my colleagues’ reactions, and I watch to see if the conductor gives players confidence but also keeps a tight rein — and if the conductor sees himself as the main protagonist or the composer.”
This year, one composer will be close at hand; the program includes two arrangements by Timothy Higgins, the CSO’s relatively new principal trombone. Higgins, a former student of Mulcahy’s at Northwestern University, did brass settings of pieces by Gabrieli and John Williams, two composers at the opposite ends of the classical chronology.
Although Mulcahy has been the program’s conductor since 2007, “Everyone having a voice makes a stronger team,“ he said. ”People have plenty of suggestions, and I take as many as I can, but we take the responsibility of the Chicago Symphony seriously.”

