Skip to main content
Setting the tone from the podium and aiming to maximize audience engagement

Conductor Thomas Wilkins believes in making merry, and not just at the holidays

In author Michael Connelly’s popular “Bosch” police procedural novels, the title character, LAPD detective Harry Bosch, has a credo: “Either everybody counts or nobody counts.” Veteran maestro Thomas Wilkins, a professed Bosch fan, approaches his work with the same philosophy in mind. “Either everybody in the audience counts, or nobody counts,” Wilkins says during a recent conversation from his home in St. Petersburg, Florida. “And in a piece, either every note counts or no note counts.” 

That holds true across the board, whether Wilkins — who is also principal conductor of the Hollywood Bowl Orchestra — is conducting Mahler’s Symphony No. 2 or Beethoven’s Symphony No. 3. Or the Chicago Symphony Orchestra’s annual Merry, Merry Chicago! concerts, as he did in 2023 and will do again this year Dec. 18-23 at Symphony Center.

Those always jam-packed holiday extravaganzas are among the CSO’s most beloved events. Wilkins says they’re also among its most important, and for this reason: They introduce classical music to people of all ages who’ve never experienced it live, let alone at a world-class level. The hope is that once they get a taste, some will return for subsequent programs. Not only is much of the CSO’s holiday repertoire more accessible and familiar than usual, the entire setting is notably more informal. A big part of maintaining that inviting atmosphere falls to the conductor, and Wilkins is a proven master of audience engagement and breaking the all-too-often tall and opaque fourth wall.

“Someone said to me a long time ago that you don’t ever want to underestimate [an audience’s] intelligence or overestimate their ignorance,” Wilkins says. “It’s not that you read the room, but you read the situation that you’re in. And I’ve learned over the years that sometimes I have to be a teacher when I’m talking to an audience; I want to give them information that enhances their listening or enhances their understanding. Sometimes I’m a storyteller. Sometimes I’m funny.”

And sometimes all that’s called for is a quick hello-and-thanks to let people know they’re not invisible, that he and the orchestra appreciate their presence.

This personal and tangible approach is so important to Wilkins, and not only at holiday concerts, that his students at Indiana University’s Jacobs School of Music  — where he’s been the Henry A. Upper Chair of Orchestral Conducting and Professor of Music since 2017 — are required to hone podium skills that go beyond the musical realm.

Learning how to engage audiences verbally and nonverbally is especially crucial for programs that are oriented toward children, or where many children are present (holiday shows certainly fit the latter bill). Says Wilkins, “The first thing I want the kids to do is have fun, because if they’re ever invited to an orchestra concert again, I don’t want them to say, ‘No, I’m not going. It was too serious. It was too stiff. I had to sit still and couldn’t wiggle.’

"You also have to remove the brick wall that exists between the stage and the audience so people feel comfortable almost right away. Then they’re ready, because they feel like you’re not talking down to them; you’re just having a conversation with them. The third thing that I want audiences to understand is that the music these composers wrote, even if it was 150 years ago, has a direct relationship to their everyday lives.”

Expect all of that (along with typically top-notching music-making) at this year’s Merry, Merry performances, which also will feature the vocal stylings of actress and renowned Broadway performer Mandy Gonzalez in a program that reflects the holiday theme but isn’t just comprised of old chestnuts.

Some numbers aren’t even holiday tunes, per se. Light Calvary Overture (Suppé), for instance, and “Que Sera, Sera” (Livingston and Evans, arr. Connors). But even they, Wilkins points out, have a holiday-esque spirit. “We don’t want the orchestra to be playing what we call a bunch of ‘footballs’ all night long — whole notes over and over again,” he says. “We want to give them something that engages them and makes the orchestra sound good.”

That’s because if the orchestra is fully engaged, the audience will be, too. “An audience can actually see the enthusiasm in the players, and subsequently hear the enthusiasm in the players,“ he says. ”And then the players react to the fact that the audience has reacted to their enthusiasm.”

But it all trickles down from him, Wilkins knows. He sets the tone. And he always strives for that tone, whether it’s conveyed in words or actions, to be as warm and welcoming as possible. “I will often say to an audience at a holiday concert that with all the stuff they have to do — shopping and gift-wrapping and cooking and baking — congratulations for just taking a moment to pause and let some great holiday music wash over you.

"We want to affirm the fact that they have stopped everything they’re doing in the holiday season, as crazy as it is, and just said, ‘I’m going to go hear my orchestra and listen to great music and just pause.’ ”