Skip to main content
Civic Fellows reflect on Notes for Peace

Healing through song

Notes for Peace concert at the Epiphany Center for the Arts on October 17, 2026.

Elliot Mandel

In October, musicians and families gathered to connect, reflect and pay tribute to loved ones lost to gun violence as part of Notes for Peace, a program of the Chicago Symphony Negaunee Music Institute that is now in its ninth year. Civic Fellows play a key role in this work, listening to stories and creating music with families from Purpose Over Pain. Their songwriting training is supported by colleagues Sara Lee and Rex Horan from the Irene Taylor Trust, who are expert teaching artists in collaborative songwriting processes. In just the span of two weeks, eight new songs of tribute were composed this fall; the songs were then recorded for future release on notesforpeace.org and shared at a free concert on October 17 at Epiphany Center for the Arts.  

Families and Civic Orchestra musicians gather at the Epiphany Center for the Arts after an October 2026 Notes for Peace performance.

Elliot Mandel

Four of the musicians — third-year Civic Fellow Kari Novilla (harp), second-year Civic Fellow Eden Stargardt (horn), first-year Civic Fellow Sarah Heimberg (trumpet) and former Civic Fellow and bassist J.T. O’Toole — shared reflections on their experience participating in the Notes for Peace project. 

Third-year Civic Fellow Kari Novilla (harp) and parent Demetric Brown talk together on the first day of the Notes for Peace songwriting workshop.

Todd Rosenberg Photography

First-year Civic Fellow Sarah Heimberg (trumpet) and second-year Civic Fellow Justine Teo (violin) join Annessa Robinson to learn about her son Cyrus before writing a new song to honor him.

Todd Rosenberg Photography

As musicians and family members meet for the first time, mutual trust and connection are built together. Eden Stargardt remembered some important guidance she received in her first year, to “lead with your care and curiosity and just be human.“ Kari Novilla explained that ”when someone trusts you with something that personal, your job is to listen well and carry her story with care in the music." Sarah Heimberg, who was new to the process this year, said, “I was so moved to see the amount of joy that Annessa seemed to have when she heard the song we wrote for Cyrus. We were all smiling through tears at the vocal recordings.”   

Second-year Civic Fellow Eden Stargardt (horn) performs in a quintet during the Notes for Peace project kickoff meeting with families from Purpose Over Pain.

Todd Rosenberg Photography

Third-year Civic Fellow Kari Novilla (harp) and second-year Civic Fellow Justine Teo (violin) connect with a family member on concert day.

Elliot Mandel

Civic Fellows work closely with family members but also work on the craft of songwriting with support from Sara Lee and Rex Horan from the Irene Taylor Trust. J.T. O’Toole, who participated in Notes for Peace projects during his time in the Civic Fellowship, says “Rex and Sara are the best of the best. They are both so genuinely invested in not only the families they work with, but everyone around them.” Novilla added, “Sara and Rex are not only so kind but so richly talented and just being around them was a gift. They supported us at every step, from first idea to finished song, and they made us feel that our voices mattered in the process.” “They are some of the kindest, most supportive humans I’ve ever met,” said Stargardt. “I don’t know how they do it, but they really make the songwriting process feel approachable.” Heimberg, who was writing songs for the first time, was grateful for the collaboration. She said, “my partner and I felt like there were a few things that were not quite right in our song. Sara, Rex and I spent a few hours working out the issues the next morning, and it came out so much better than we could have expected.”

Stargardt summed it up saying, “I never would have considered myself someone who would be capable of writing a song prior to this project, and it really expanded what I believed was possible for applying my musical training beyond the concert stage.”    

“I never would have considered myself someone who would be capable of writing a song prior to this project, and it really expanded what I believed was possible for applying my musical training beyond the concert stage.” 
- Eden Stargardt, Civic Fellow (horn)

Sara Lee from the Irene Taylor Trust listens as family member shares a remembrance before the October 17 Notes for Peace concert.

Elliot Mandel

Rex Horan from the Irene Taylor Trust greets family members following the Notes for Peace performance.

Elliot Mandel

Another aspect of the Notes for Peace project is recording the new songs of tribute. Since the project began, recording engineer Mathieu Lejeune has recorded every Notes for Peace song that has been written. Stargardt reflected on a previous experience of recording a song, saying, “Last year, my parent came to the recording session and was already singing along to the song we created for her daughter. That was a really impactful moment for me because it showed me just how much the song meant to her.”

Families from Purpose Over Pain gather at St. Sabina Church in Chicago to share stories of their loved ones lost to gun violence that turn into songs of healing and tribute through the Notes for Peace program.

Todd Rosenberg Photography

Musicians also responded to the unique conditions of recording music together, with Novilla sharing, “(the) challenge was the limited time and tight schedule for the day, but that pressure also kept us focused and present, and I think it brought out something genuine in the recordings.” She added, “recording with the (Civic) Fellows is always special because making music with friends is easy.” Stargardt acknowledged some of the challenges of the process, saying, “In the studio, each instrument group is separated in different rooms, which feels really unnatural compared to playing in an orchestra where we’re used to hearing each other live. It’s a lot of people to coordinate with in a way that we’re not used to.” Overall, the process yielded rewards as Heimberg noted, “Although I have recorded myself on many occasions, this was the first time I sat in a recording studio with other musicians. I typically find recording to be stressful, but it was so much better with friends in the studio with me.” 

First-year Civic Fellows Sarah Heimberg (trumpet) and Erin Harrigan (horn) performing at Epiphany Center for the Arts.

Elliot Mandel

The day of a Notes for Peace performance is an emotional moment for everyone who has been part of creating the new songs and honoring loved ones lost to gun violence. It’s also a time of reflection and hope. Thinking about this year’s performance at Epiphany Center for the Arts, J.T. O’Toole said, “I was so proud of Melinda, the mother who I collaborated with for this project. She came up on stage to speak before the song we wrote began, and I could tell that it was incredibly difficult for her. Despite how hard it was, she was able to share a touching tribute to her son, Jacob.” Kari Novilla added, “You could sense the love, the grief, and the weight of it all at once, and the music seemed to hold space for every bit of it. In those moments, the families, the audience, and the musicians felt like one community.” Eden Stargardt said, "This year was especially emotional, and seeing the parents support each other throughout the rehearsals and in the concert was a testament to the strength of that community. Getting to be a part of sharing these stories was incredibly special.” 

“You could sense the love, the grief, and the weight of it all at once, and the music seemed to hold space for every bit of it. In those moments, the families, the audience, and the musicians felt like one community.” 
-Kari Novilla, Civic Fellow (harp)

Civic Fellow alum J.T. O'Toole hugs parent Melinda Abdallah following performance of their song.

Elliot Mandel

Civic Orchestra musicians and family members at the October 17 Notes for Peace performance at Epiphany Center for the Arts.

Elliot Mandel

Civic Fellows who have participated in Notes for Peace don’t hesitate when thinking about the opportunity to be part of it again.  O’Toole says, “There is no other project like Notes for Peace. There is a directness in this project that is hard to find as a classical musician, and I would jump at the opportunity to be part of this again.” Novilla added, “This work is so closely tied to what music means to me. Music has an amazing capacity to heal and to give a voice to people who might otherwise go unheard. Helping turn loss into remembrance, and remembrance into community, is something I’d be honored to do again.”