Composer John Powell believes live-to-picture concerts attract new audiences to classical music. "New generations can enjoy the orchestra as a sonic medium,“ Powell said. ”It’s a wonderful thing. It’s not quite a film and not quite a concert.”
John Powell Music
Live-to-picture orchestral performances are drawing more attention to the role of film composers like John Powell, who usually work in the background.
“I’m incredibly flattered that so many orchestras are picking this up,” said Powell of the live-to-picture phenomenon, in which film scores are performed live while the movie is projected above the stage. The Oscar-nominated composer is known for his work on “Shrek” (2001), “Kung-Fu Panda” (2008) and the “How to Train Your Dragon” series. The Chicago Symphony Orchestra presented the first title in the ’Dragon" series last season for a sold-out run. This season, the CSO will perform Powell’s “How to Train Your Dragon 2” (2014), conducted by Nicholas Buc, on Nov. 27-29. “New generations can enjoy the orchestra as a sonic medium,“ Powell said. ”It’s a wonderful thing. It’s not quite a film and not quite a concert.”
Powell’s film-score career began because he had no job prospects after getting a university degree in composition. He wrote some background music for commercials to bring in some money, then got hired to assist a more established composer on a big project and advanced from there. To date, he has composed soundtracks for more than 70 feature films, including 10 for DreamWorks Animation. Along with two Oscar nominations, he has won two Annie Awards (the Academy Awards of the animation industry) for his music for the first two “How to Train Your Dragon” films.
“A composer gets cast like anyone else — because they already like what they think you’re going to do,” said the British-born Powell, who worked with movie maestros Hans Zimmer and Harry Gregson-Williams early in his career. To succeed in film composition, Powell said, “You have to want to be in a collaborative world, and you have to be pragmatic. I always try to write with enough craft to work for everyone, but that will end up anyway as decent music.”
A film composer starts by watching the rough cut in silence, and then meeting with the director and editors to “talk about where the music goes and what it can do,” he said. Later, after Powell forms his first ideas, there will be more meetings, playing the music on a synthesizer and gathering feedback.
“Once everyone’s happy, we go into the studio,” Powell said. The score is handed over to one or more orchestrators (“I could do it myself, but it would take three or four weeks”). Then with a conductor and a full orchestra of studio musicians, the recording begins — along with further changes.
“Music as you write it wants to go places,” Powell said, “and then you realize it won’t do any good, because the scene ended. If you write three minutes of music for a two-minute scene, you can’t just cut one minute. You have to rewrite the whole thing to get it to the right place at the right time.”
A composer of a film score has much less autonomy than a composer of a quartet or a symphony. Powell has written chamber music and an oratorio, and found the genres “both harder and easier” than film work. Working in the group setting of movies, he said, “I learned early on that that if one person is a boss and one person is not a boss, your ego doesn’t like that. And I decided that the film, the story, is the boss.”
That works well for his approach to music, because “I’m a composer first, but I realized that I liked being part of the film collective, and I’m also a storyteller,“ he saie. ”If I go to a concert and listen to a symphony, I’m hearing a story.”
Live performances of film scores have become very popular, but that popularity puts a burden on an orchestra, because the scores were never meant to be played straight through; the original studio soundtrack is produced over a period of days or weeks. “I apologize to the brass section,” Powell said. “It’s like [performing] three Mahler symphonies [in one session]. But the orchestras are amazing. They’re getting superhuman about it.”
To prepare a score for live performance, Powell and an assistant will go through and simplify matters. In the recording studio, he might use 12 horns and six trumpets to get a bigger sound, but that isn’t needed in a resonant concert hall, he said. The sound effects on the soundtrack will be dialed back, and subtitles are added for the dialogue, in case the recorded words are lost under the live music.
Though he appreciates the popularity of live-to-picture concerts of his scores, with “great orchestras around the world [performing] things of mine," he usually doesn’t "get to go [to the concerts]. Chicago’s brass section is world-famous. I would love to turn up for the Chicago Symphony.”
The teen Viking hero Hiccup and his pal Toothless return for more adventures in "How to Train Your Dragon 2" (2014). The movie won the 2015 Golden Globe for best animated feature film and the 2015 Annie Award in the same category.
DreamWorks Animation

