Skip to main content

Boo! It’s Charles Ives’ ‘Hallowe’en,’ unfolding in sustained burst of energy

Charles Ives, in a detail from an illustration used on a Deutsche Grammophon disc of his works, including "Hallowe'en," originally recorded in 1988-87 with Leonard Bernstein and the New York Philharmonic.

Charles Ives displays his whimsical side in Hallowe’en (1907), scored for “string quartet, piano and optional drum.” He called it “a takeoff of a Halloween party and bonfire — the elfishness of the little boys throwing wood on the fire … it is a joke that even Herbert Hoover could get.”  

Hallowe’en is part of a CSO chamber music program titled “City Rhythms,” presented Sept. 29 at the Driehaus Museum. The performers are CSO violins Yuan-Qing Yu and Ni Mei, viola Danny Lai, cello Katinka Kleijn and guest pianist Kuang-Hao Huang. The program explores the energy, rhythm and humanity of city life through works by Gershwin, Ives, Price and Bloch, all evoking the vitality of urban America. Also on the program are Gershwin’s Lullaby, Florence Price’s Adoration, two Largo risolutos by Ives and Bloch’s Piano Quintet No. 1.

The impetus for the program is the Driehaus Museum’s newly acquired collection of 32 lithographs by Ashcan School artist George Bellows, dating from 1897 to 1924, depicting Chicago scenes along Michigan Avenue and Adams Street.

Ives described Hallowe’en as beginning with “a whisper, with only two voices, the second violin and cello. Increasing in speed and cacophony, it enters the world of polytonality, with each voice entering into scales in its own distinct key (C major for the first violin, B major for the second violin, D-flat major for the viola and D major for the cello). Ghostly canons emerge in the counterpoint. The rollicking party ends with cadential chords that veer away from a C major resolution in a final practical joke.”

Ives also called Hallowe’en “one of the most carefully worked out [compositions] (technically speaking), and one of the best pieces (from the standpoint of workmanship) that I’ve ever done.”

Hallowe’en is part of Ives’ Three Outdoor Pieces, including The Pond and The Gong on the Hook and Ladder. Composed in a single continuous movement, which lasts only a few minutes, the work unfolds as one unbroken burst of energy from start to finish. Listen for a short rhythmic pattern that repeats insistently in the piano and strings, almost like a dance that will not stop, evoking children running wild on a Halloween night. Ives layers the instruments so they seem to be playing in different keys at once, creating a constant, good-natured clash, rather than a smooth blend. This is the “bitonal” effect that he liked to use to depict chaos or crowds. 

Ives reportedly asked performers to play faster and faster as the piece proceeds, so listen for the tempo pushing forward until the music seems to spin out of control before it suddenly stops, according to Schott Music, Ives’ publisher. There is no lyrical melody to hum afterward, the interest lies in the raw rhythmic drive and the collision of harmonies, “a glimpse of Ives experimenting with sounds far ahead of his time.”